3 Comments
User's avatar
Michael Ginsburg's avatar

I don't normally watch Redacted after discovering they shill for the Wellness Company but have decided to do so this time solely because of your appearance and the topic discussed.

Overall it was good but I must take issue with your statement along the lines that the primary (or even sole) objective of Hamas in launching October 7 was to take hostages to be used later for a prisoner exchange deal.

Respectfully, the footage from that day simply does NOT support that:

https://actionabletruth.substack.com/i/145746766/there-is-no-denying-that-hamas-did-come-to-kill-not-just-take-hostages

Hamas did NOT behave in any way as a legitimate fighting force that day and as such, its fighters are NOT entitled to ANY protection under the international conventions of war,

https://rumble.com/v5tuxpn-october-7-as-captured-through-hamas-cameras.html

https://rumble.com/v5v5qyt-october-7-blue-shirts-raw-footage.html

Expand full comment
Paul Savage's avatar

Just want to clarify how you feel about the isrealis that clearly commit war crimes likely daily.

Yes if hammas broke the rules of war (sort of a funny idea eh) then they should be held to account, but just be fair about applying the human garbage label less you fall into a pit of refuse yourself.

You seem to have some scruples and a desire to find the truth, please don't let hatred cloud your judgement

You are more useful to us not beholden to the whims of emotional and hatred.

Take care

Expand full comment
Michael Ginsburg's avatar

For the avoidance of doubt:

1. I am referring ONLY to the Hamas members who were involved in October 7.

2. I am definitely NOT saying the Palestinians as a whole are "human garbage". Not for a second!

Expand full comment